“Is GEO the new SEO, and do I need a special framework for it?” Two agency camps answer differently, and both profit from the confusion. Before picking a side, read what Google wrote. It clarifies what Google says about its own Search features and where that guidance stops. By the end you will know which claims Google supports for Search and which questions about other assistants remain open.
What Google actually says
Google’s guide, updated July 10, 2026, says foundational SEO best practices remain relevant to its generative AI features in Google Search. It discusses technically sound, crawlable pages and useful content in that Google Search context. Read Google’s guide to generative AI features in Search. This guidance does not establish how ChatGPT or other assistants work.
The guide also says the following are not requirements for Google’s generative AI Search features:
- llms.txt. Google says it does not use this file for Google Search and that it neither helps nor harms visibility there. The guide notes that other services may use these files.
- Breaking content into tiny pieces. Google says there is no requirement to split content into tiny pieces for its generative AI Search features.
- Special markup for Google AI features. Google says no special markup is required for AI Overviews or AI Mode. The page still needs to meet Google Search eligibility requirements, and appearance is not guaranteed (https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-features).
- Inauthentic mentions. Google says seeking inauthentic mentions across the web is not as helpful for its generative AI Search features as it might seem. Its guide says Google’s ranking systems focus on high-quality content and other systems block spam.
These are Google’s statements about its own Search products. They do not establish what other assistants use or require.
Where both camps are wrong
Camp one sells GEO as a new discipline with secret frameworks and special files. For Google Search, Google’s guide says some of these files are not requirements for its generative AI features. That does not determine how other assistants work. Useful content and sound SEO foundations remain part of the work.
Camp two says “GEO is hype, it is just SEO”, and stops there. Google’s guide says foundational SEO practices remain relevant to its generative AI Search features, but it does not settle how other assistants answer. A harder question remains, and no SEO tool answers it:
- Does ChatGPT recommend you when someone asks for your category?
- Which competitors does it name instead of you?
- Which sources do the answers come from?
- Is any of that changing month over month?
Classic reporting cannot answer those questions, because assistants produce answers, not rankings. There is no position to track, and the same question returns different brands on different runs. What the debate calls GEO includes two distinct questions: how to apply Google’s documented SEO foundations to its Search features, and how to measure what other assistants answer.
The part that is actually new
Measurement means running a real instrument: a bank of category questions, asked the way buyers ask them, sent to several AI models, repeated, with every response read and counted. Rates with denominators, not vibes or one lucky screenshot.
It also means knowing your sources: the domains the assistants cite for your category, ordered by who can influence them. Usually that list is uncomfortable. For a consumer brand it is retailers, regulators and review platforms. For a B2B it is comparison sites, business media and forums. The brand’s own site is one voice among many, and rarely the loudest.
None of that appears in a Search Console report. All of it is measurable, with a method you can inspect and repeat.
What to do with this
If an agency sells llms.txt or special schema as requirements for Google’s generative AI Search features, compare that claim with the Google guide above. If an agency says “it is all just SEO”, ask how it knows whether assistants recommend you this month, and against whom. Watch what happens to the conversation.
One more thing worth carrying into any pitch: what a serious provider commits to is the instrument and the run — a prompt bank complete and useful for your industry, and a study that produces findings you can act on. What nobody commits to, us included, is that the actions you take afterwards will move the numbers in the next measurement. The method is public precisely so you can judge the findings, not the promise.
Optimization you probably already do, or should. Measurement is the missing half, and it is the part worth arguing about. The page on /agencia-geo-mexico/ is that half in practice: a frozen bank of category questions, run across several models, with rates and sources you can inspect.